Pumpkin, Butterfly, and Floral Cookie Set...from ONE cookie cutter!

pumpkin, butterfly, and floral cookies for fall...made from ONE cookie cutter!


how to make Monarch butterfly cookies from a pumpkin cookie cutter

Does it seem odd to mix pumpkins with butterflies? Not around here in the Houston area. We do get our butterflies in spring, but in fall, when Monarchs are heading to Mexico for the winter, they make a little stop here. 


pumpkin, butterfly, and floral cookies for fall...made from ONE cookie cutter!

It seems silly, but I've had this idea in my head for a while but hesitated to make them. I LOVE butterflies but have never been thrilled with how my butterfly cookies have turned out. So, I psyched myself out and never made them again. 


Making three cookies from just one cookie cutter. 

What's cool about this cookie set is that all three cookies are made with the same pumpkin cookie cutter. You can use any one you have...or even different sizes! When I make this set again, and I will, I'll probably make the floral one with a smaller pumpkin cutter. (Yes, I have about 5 pumpkin cookie cutters. Doesn't everyone?) 


monarch butterfly cookie made from a pumpkin cookie cutter!

I am pretty much in love with the profile butterfly cookie. THIS is probably how I'll make my butterflies from now on. The pumpkin shape is perfect for the wings and to add the antennae. 


pumpkin, butterfly, and floral cookies for fall...made from ONE cookie cutter!


Next week, I'll walk you through the simple pumpkin cookies in this set, but today, let's make the butterfly cookies! 


You'll need:


Cut the cookie dough into pumpkin shapes and bake as directed.


Use a #2 tip to outline the pumpkins in green. Thin the icing with water, a bit at a time, until the icing is the consistency of glue. A ribbon of icing dropped back onto itself should disappear in a three-second count. If it is too thin, stir in more piping consistency icing or powdered sugar. Cover with a damp dishtowel and let sit several minutes. (The icing is a bit more green in real life...a light avocado.)


Stir gently to pop any air bubbles and pour into a squeeze bottle. Fill in the outline. Use a toothpick to guide to edges and pop any large air bubbles. Let the icing dry at least one hour. 


how to decorate a monarch butterfly cookie


Use black icing and #2 tip to pipe the outline of the butterfly on the green icing. Outline the body, wing sections, and antenna. 


Thin the two tones of orange icing and the remaining black icing as directed above. Pour the icing into squeeze bottles. If possible, use a bottle with a removable tip for the black icing and use a #1 or #1.5 tip. Working about 6 cookies at a time, flood the top center section of the wings with dark orange and the bottom section with light orange.


Start with the first filled cookie. On top of the wet orange icing, pipe lines with the thinned black icing. Let this icing set for an hour or so before filling in the black areas.


how to decorate a monarch butterfly cookie

how to: butterfly cookie tutorial

Thin the white icing as above. Pour into a squeeze bottle fitted with a #1 or #1.5 tip. Fill in the black sections of the wings and the body. Drop dots of white onto the wet black icing. 


monarch butterfly cookie decorating tutorial

Let the cookies dry 6-8 hours or overnight. 


pumpkin, butterfly, and floral cookies for fall...made from ONE cookie cutter!

The butterflies are perfectly lovely on their own or pair them with pumpkins and flower cookies! 


I am a certified crazy butterfly lady. 

Thanks to the influence of one very cool aunt, my garden has milkweed for Monarch caterpillars in the front and back yard. We have all sorts of flowers that they love, and I'm working on adding more host plants for other types of butterflies. The Swallowwails seems to love our little wafer ash tree! 


pumpkins and butterflies made using the same cookie cutter

Here's my Instagram video of a Monarch emerging from its chrysalis in our backyard. I still get, um...butterflies (?) every time I watch it! 


pumpkin, butterfly, and floral cookies for fall...made from ONE cookie cutter!

Cheers to butterflies, pumpkins, flowers, AND cookies! 




1 comment

Thank you so much for taking the time to comment! If you have a recipe question, please reach out on twitter or instagram. :)