Sweet on Trader Joe's Sunday : Mudd Pie

a review of Trader Joe's Mudd Pie | from a weekly #traderjoes review series

We want to make sure you guys are ready for Fat Tuesday. I had something else in my cart to review but put it back as soon as I spied this baby. It looked decadent and just the ticket for a splurge before Lent.

a review of Trader Joe's Mudd Pie | from a weekly #traderjoes review series

a review of Trader Joe's Mudd Pie | from a bakeat350.net weekly #traderjoes review series

Trader Joe's Mudd Pie is an ice cream pie, and I misplaced my receipt, so I'm going to guess it's in the neighborhood of 5 bucks. Described by Trader Joe's as "coffee ice cream with a fudge swirl in a chocolate crust."

[Note: be careful as you cut into it...I got a little forceful with the knife and went all the way through the foil pan.]

a review of Trader Joe's Mudd Pie | from a weekly #traderjoes review series

A mom's (my) take: I was immediately impressed with the interior packaging. That little plastic box kept the pie in perfect shape and is so nice for storing leftover pie. Let's get to the nitty-gritty. This Mudd Pie is awesome. The coffee flavor is just right, the chocolate crust is dark and crisp without being too crunchy, and the fudge layer between the crust and the ice cream? Well, that just takes it from really good to breakoutthefatpants. You can see from the picture that the top of the crust fell apart a little when removing it from the pan. If it happens to you, the pie is so good, you'll forget on the first bite.
Overall rating: 5 of 5 stars

A teenager's (Jack's) take: Although I was eating this pie in a rush to get somewhere, I still got a good impression of it. The ice cream base has a great consistency, but the tinge of coffee flavor just isn't my type. The chocolate dollops on the top were amazing, as were the crust. The "side crust" is especially awesome. You may have to sacrifice the color of your teeth, but I think the taste experience of this pie will probably be worth it.
Overall rating: 4 out of 5 stars

a review of Trader Joe's Mudd Pie

Trader Joe's Mudd Pie: if coffee's your thing, this pie's for you. 

[note: We have no affiliation with Trader Joe's. I'm sure they have never read this blog and have no idea who we are. Hey, we like being incognito, although we never wear sunglasses indoors. ;)]

Read all of our reviews of Trader Joe's treats and sweets here!



  1. Love the alum.pn mishap..you are so strong!

    Bridget..I think TJs should know about you..can I write to them?
    I mean..I have often bought things just because of you!

  2. Bridget, I was afraid to open this post, so fearful of deliciousness! And, rightfully so! I usually am sad Trader Joe's has no locations closer than 25 minutes from my home, even though I ask them to please build one closer, look at the demographics in Gilbert, AZ, I mean, really? But, now I might be GLAD they aren't closer. TOO MANY yummy new things, all the time, every season!

  3. Oh, Trader Joe's is def on my list of places to go tomorrow - mud pie for dessert, please! We love coffee and chocolate here - can't wait to try it.

  4. This Mudd Pie is indeed awesome--and coming from someone who isn't crazy about most "sweets." Great mix of real coffee flavor and chocolate accents. SO glad there's a TJ's at the end of mu block, just a minute's walk away!


Thank you so much for taking the time to comment! If you have a recipe question, please reach out on twitter or instagram. :)

Blogger Template by pipdig